Vent, Valve & Volt
Faucet handle loose, wobbly or spinning all the way around

You can fix this

Likely cause: a stripped spigot handle or stem

An outdoor spigot handle that spins usually has a stripped handle. If a new handle spins too, the stem inside is worn or broken.

Why this happens

A spigot's wheel handle grips the stem through a broach, a shaped hole that must match the stem tip. Danco makes metal wheel handles to replace a lost or stripped handle on hose bibbs, sillcocks and stopcocks, sold by broach, for example a 12 point round broach. This Old House says compression valves are the most common outdoor type, and that on old gate-valve spigots the stem is prone to breaking.

How to fix it

  1. Pull the handle screw and the handle. Look at the hole and the stem tip and note the broach: round with a count of points, or square. Take the old handle to match it.
  2. If the hole is chewed but the stem tip is crisp, fit a new wheel handle with the same broach and tighten the screw.
  3. If the stem tip is rounded or the stem turns without changing the flow, shut off the water to the spigot and open the spigot to relieve pressure, as This Old House directs.
  4. This Old House: loosen the bonnet nut with tongue-and-groove pliers and unscrew the stem from the body. Take it with you to match the stem or the spigot.
  5. While it is out, This Old House replaces the washer smooth side down, wraps Teflon packing about 1 1/4 times around the stem thread under the packing nut, and dresses the seat with a reseating tool.
  6. When you close the spigot from now on, stop at snug. This Old House lists overtightening the handle when closing the valve as a habit to avoid.

When to stop. If the shutoff for the spigot will not close by hand, or it drips when you move it, leave it alone and call a plumber; Bob Vila warns a rusted or worn valve may break if you try to use it. If there is no shutoff for the spigot and the main will not close, or the stem is a long frost-free type that runs into the wall, stop; This Old House notes that type keeps its shutoff valve inside the house, so a broken stem means work inside the wall for a plumber.

If this does not fix it, tell the plumber

  • It is an outdoor spigot whose handle spins, and whether a new handle fixed it.
  • Whether the spigot has its own shutoff inside.
  • Whether it is a long frost-free type or a short spigot.

Build the full list: what to tell the plumber.

Not quite what you are seeing? Other results in this troubleshooter: Call a plumber: the shutoff won't close; a loose set screw or retainer; a broken cartridge or connector; a loose handle screw; a stripped handle or stem tip; a missing or flipped stem stop; a broken stem on that side.

Start this troubleshooter over

FourHome is our sister brand. Browse all FourHome replacement faucet and shower parts on the FourHome Amazon store. We earn from purchases made through this link.