Vent, Valve & Volt
Faucet handle loose, wobbly or spinning all the way around

This one needs a licensed pro

Call a plumber: the shutoff won't close

The handle no longer stops the water and the shutoff will not close. Leave that valve alone, close the main, and call a plumber.

Why this happens

When a handle spins, the water stays wherever the broken stem or cartridge left it, so the shutoff is your only control. Moen says faucet shutoffs close by turning clockwise until tight, and that sometimes the only shutoff is the main for the whole house. Bob Vila warns that a valve that is rusted, aged, badly worn or leaking may break if you use it, and says to have a plumber replace it instead.

What to do right now

  1. Open the sink stopper so the running water drains instead of filling the bowl.
  2. Leave the stuck or leaking shutoff alone. Do not put a wrench or pliers on its handle; Bob Vila warns a rusted or worn valve may break if you try to use it.
  3. Close the main shutoff. Moen says it is usually near the water meter: the basement, garage, crawl space, an outside wall or near the street. Bob Vila says a lever ball valve is off when it is turned 90 degrees to sit across the pipe.
  4. If the main will not turn either, call your water utility. Bob Vila notes the valve at the meter may be for the city's use only.
  5. Once the main is closed, let the faucet run until it stops and set a towel under the sink.
  6. Ask the plumber to replace the stuck stop as well as repair the faucet. Family Handyman says modern quarter-turn ball valves rarely lock up, leak or wear out.

When to stop. Never force a stuck shutoff. If the main will not close either, stop and call the water utility.

What to tell the plumber

  • Which faucet spins and that it will not shut off.
  • Which shutoff is stuck or leaking, and whether it has a round handle or a lever.
  • Whether you closed the main, and where it is.
  • That you would like the stop replaced with a quarter-turn valve.

Build the full list: what to tell the plumber.

Not quite what you are seeing? Other results in this troubleshooter: a loose set screw or retainer; a broken cartridge or connector; a loose handle screw; a stripped handle or stem tip; a missing or flipped stem stop; a broken stem on that side; a stripped spigot handle or stem.

Start this troubleshooter over

FourHome is our sister brand. Browse all FourHome replacement faucet and shower parts on the FourHome Amazon store. We earn from purchases made through this link.