This one needs a licensed pro
Call a plumber: the shutoff valve itself is failing
A shutoff that is stuck, leaking or whistling on its own needs a plumber, and it is a good time to ask about a quarter-turn ball valve.
Why this happens
This Old House says the multi-turn valve is the standard shutoff under nearly every sink, that compression valves seal by pressing a rubber or fiber washer against a seat, and that ball valves tend to be quieter than traditional stem valves. Its expert Richard Trethewey says green buildup on a brass or copper valve is a strong sign water has been escaping. Family Handyman's plumbing source says a valve that keeps leaking after tightening, is badly corroded, or will not turn calls for a plumber, and warns that over-tightening the nut can crack the valve.
What to do right now
- Do not force the valve or crank on its nut. Family Handyman warns that over-tightening can crack the valve or crush the washer inside.
- Put a towel and a small bowl under a dripping valve and check it every few hours.
- If water is spraying or pooling, close the main water valve by hand. This Old House says never to jerk or force the main; turn it slowly and steadily. If the main will not move, leave it and call your water utility and a plumber.
- Call a licensed plumber to replace the shutoff. Ask about a quarter-turn ball valve, which This Old House says tends to be quieter.
When to stop. Any water spraying or pooling, or a main valve that will not turn, means call a plumber now. Never force either valve.
What to tell the plumber
- Which shutoff is stuck, leaking or noisy, hot or cold.
- Whether you see green buildup or corrosion on it.
- Whether the faucet noise changes as you open or close that valve.
- Whether you closed the main to stop a leak.
Build the full list: what to tell the plumber.
Not quite what you are seeing? Other results in this troubleshooter: water hammer, not the faucet; Call a plumber: water pressure may be too high; Call a plumber: every hot tap whistles; a shutoff left partly closed; a clogged or loose aerator; a loose or worn washer on the stem; debris in or wear on the cartridge.
Start this troubleshooter over
FourHome is our sister brand. Browse all FourHome replacement faucet and shower parts on the FourHome Amazon store. We earn from purchases made through this link.