This one needs a licensed pro
Likely cause: a worn flush valve seat or overflow tube
If a new flapper still leaks, the seat it closes against, or the overflow tube assembly, may be the problem. On a two-piece toilet that is a plumber's job.
Why this happens
A flapper can only seal against a smooth, intact flush valve seat. Family Handyman says the overflow tube may be incorrectly sized, and that when you just can't find a flapper that seals on a two-piece toilet it is time to call a plumber. Korky notes the flush valve seal itself can be what lets water leak into the bowl.
What to do right now
- Run the dye test once more with the new flapper to confirm the leak is still there.
- Check that the flapper matches the flush valve size, 2 inch or 3 inch.
- Turn off the toilet's supply stop if the running bothers you, and turn it back on to flush.
- Call a plumber about the flush valve and overflow tube.
What to tell the plumber
- A new flapper still leaks and the dye test still shows color.
- Whether it is a one-piece or two-piece toilet.
- The flapper size you tried.
Build the full list: what to tell the plumber.
Not quite what you are seeing? Other results in this troubleshooter: a worn flapper; a chain that keeps the flapper from sealing; the water level is set too high; a worn or stuck fill valve.
Start this troubleshooter over
FourHome is our sister brand. Browse all FourHome replacement faucet and shower parts on the FourHome Amazon store. We earn from purchases made through this link.